{"schemaVersion":1,"baselineManifest":{"schemaVersion":1,"kind":"immutable-baseline","capturedAt":"2026-08-29T00:00:00-04:00","sourceMeasuredAt":"2026-08-28","gitCommit":"f1d4c3cd992c1a47a1c75ff6ba6c655254afcf23","resultsFile":"results/compressors.json","resultsSha256":"1dcec905ea9256f26ac25037868960278793a771cb96852c355b88e1eec2cbb2","resultsBytes":28129,"notes":["This manifest freezes the pre-redesign benchmark. New benchmark runs must write a versioned result file and must not replace results/compressors.json.","The pre-redesign Census Balanced output has a known DeviceCMYK colour-conversion defect on page 19; it remains part of the baseline rather than being edited away."],"corpus":[{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","bytes":6813639,"sha256":"6478b6e571a7d6fcd846d8ef77bfd60c285f1986abb8f475eedc43de403074f5"},{"file":"budget.pdf","bytes":2417116,"sha256":"cfb0751f9ef9f60e356f4808f3231c03af802ae63a4fc0f391bdc174bd3fe28a"},{"file":"census.pdf","bytes":2724508,"sha256":"6c5d9798c31150da219cbb3cf35d478cb246e1d874eaf05f0b511336fb3b4537"},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","bytes":220237,"sha256":"3d31c226df0d189ced80e039d01cf0f8820c1019681a0f0ca6264de277b7e982"},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","bytes":3088632,"sha256":"2d2381d62c7c77ed4b64b83ac23c28ed85b7c8304eb580c09bd9fd660be0840b"}]},"baseline":{"measuredAt":"2026-08-28T19:01:51.309Z","results":[{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":2907755,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0000582226221353,"drift":2.391664282308059,"driftWorst":15.456270863137815,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":1843379,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0000582226221353,"drift":4.2129613733905575,"driftWorst":16.56833571769194,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":983351,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":0.9583919970359392,"drift":1.900410109680496,"driftWorst":7.728659990462565,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":1,"emptied":[{"page":41,"before":35.43,"after":1.37}]},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":884936,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":0.9583919970359392,"drift":2.5744396757272296,"driftWorst":13.432522651406773,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":1,"emptied":[{"page":41,"before":35.43,"after":1.37}]},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":1395510,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":0.9583919970359392,"drift":1.570214592274678,"driftWorst":7.485073915116834,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":1,"emptied":[{"page":41,"before":35.43,"after":1.37}]},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf --optimize-images","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":6165010,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0000582226221353,"drift":0.01174058178350024,"driftWorst":0.1174058178350024,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":1994302,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0000582226221353,"drift":1.1206771578445398,"driftWorst":7.081640438721984,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":1914874,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0000582226221353,"drift":1.725302813543157,"driftWorst":11.688412017167382,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","inputBytes":6813639,"outputBytes":3086463,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0000582226221353,"drift":1.0187887458273726,"driftWorst":6.337339055793992,"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","inputBytes":6813639,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":1931563,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"drift":0.6179846011033422,"driftWorst":2.7107296137339056,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":1216619,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"drift":0.7122967073372414,"driftWorst":2.7184549356223173,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":4067245,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":0.9998895472870564,"drift":8.112972878338955,"driftWorst":12.594754411063423,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":4029887,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":0.9998895472870564,"drift":8.28651569575397,"driftWorst":12.594754411063423,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":4475580,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":0.9998895472870564,"drift":0.0392194134957864,"driftWorst":0.1445887445887446,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf --optimize-images","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":2273107,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":1371030,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"drift":0.4553388404021202,"driftWorst":2.0289562289562286,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":1300448,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"drift":8.333994992289988,"driftWorst":12.580352885073914,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":2050306,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"error":"Protocol error (Target.createTarget): Target closed"},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","inputBytes":2417116,"outputBytes":1356409,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"textKept":1.0000224996267106,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":1193508,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":1.0000552125683884,"drift":5.78923329624331,"driftWorst":46.35030996661898,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":487093,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":1.0000552125683884,"drift":7.1834260583902925,"driftWorst":46.35030996661898,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":3254681,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":0.9814636349947296,"drift":5.968152059182411,"driftWorst":17.24902241297091,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":3110335,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":0.9814636349947296,"drift":7.241717470086878,"driftWorst":22.573199809251314,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":4440086,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":0.9814636349947296,"drift":0.15222118919075514,"driftWorst":0.6133524082021936,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf --optimize-images","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":2351489,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":1.0000552125683884,"drift":0.000010597149366820326,"driftWorst":0.00009537434430138292,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":697005,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":1.0000552125683884,"drift":1.6319011552798772,"driftWorst":12.124368144969004,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":569784,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":1.0000552125683884,"drift":6.166268129988142,"driftWorst":20.305102527420125,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","inputBytes":2724508,"outputBytes":1632403,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"textKept":1.0000552125683884,"drift":2.802840036030308,"driftWorst":13.565283738674298,"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","inputBytes":2724508,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":127619,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":89788,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":132169,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":1.7504530281354318,"driftWorst":2.463710061993324,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":132179,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":1.7504530281354318,"driftWorst":2.463710061993324,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":137667,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":1.7504530281354318,"driftWorst":2.463710061993324,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf --optimize-images","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":199104,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":168057,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":168064,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":213651,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","inputBytes":220237,"outputBytes":102520,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"textKept":1.0013895907023749,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":2945024,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":1.00001385052015,"drift":0.0012807411949042852,"driftWorst":0.008965188364329996,"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":1537092,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":1.00001385052015,"drift":0.08954288439266979,"driftWorst":0.4715307582260372,"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":7056010,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2955,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":7057060,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2955,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":7267608,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2955,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf --optimize-images","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":3089543,"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":1.00001385052015,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":1709735,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":1716593,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","inputBytes":3088632,"outputBytes":3109949,"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"textKept":1.00001385052015,"error":"Connection closed."},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","inputBytes":3088632,"error":"no saved output for this file"}]},"latest":{"schemaVersion":2,"measuredAt":"2026-09-01T09:14:04.644Z","methodology":{"pixelChangeThreshold":8,"visualRenderWidth":900,"perceptualMetric":"SSIM (ssim.js bezkrovny)","validity":"qpdf --check","speedNote":"Wall-clock compression time for local/browser runs. Prepared web outputs have no runtime because disk-read latency is not service latency."},"tools":[{"id":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","note":"in the browser, nothing uploaded","kind":"browser","level":"Balanced"},{"id":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","note":"the aggressive setting, for a like-for-like row against /screen","kind":"browser","level":"Smallest"},{"id":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","note":"the command most answers recommend","kind":"cli","binary":"gs"},{"id":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","note":"the aggressive preset","kind":"cli","binary":"gs"},{"id":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","note":"the preset that sounds safest","kind":"cli","binary":"gs"},{"id":"qpdf","label":"qpdf — lossless structural optimisation","note":"technical reference; no image transcoding","kind":"cli","binary":"qpdf"},{"id":"qpdf-aggressive","label":"qpdf — --optimize-images","note":"technical reference; permits image optimisation","kind":"cli","binary":"qpdf"},{"id":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","note":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","note":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com; the setting our aggressive one is measured against","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","note":"uploaded to tools.pdf24.org","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","note":"uploaded to smallpdf.com; free tier allows two downloads per 12 hours","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"adobe-default","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — default/preselected","note":"uploaded to Adobe; exact live setting is recorded in results/web/manifest.json","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"adobe-smallest","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — strongest free setting","note":"uploaded to Adobe; paid-only modes are not substituted or inferred","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"sejda-default","label":"Sejda — current defaults","note":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","kind":"prepared","uploads":true},{"id":"sejda-smallest","label":"Sejda — strongest reasonable free settings","note":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","kind":"prepared","uploads":true}],"results":[{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","configuration":"in the browser, nothing uploaded","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":8639,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2331134,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":2.108869814020028,"driftWorst":4.002002861230329,"ssimMean":0.9986453480653844,"ssimWorst":0.995725328831957,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":1.9846447305674773,"ssim":0.9992400945244068},{"page":2,"drift":4.002002861230329,"ssim":0.995725328831957},{"page":10,"drift":2.091368621840725,"ssim":0.9992420034994908},{"page":15,"drift":2.634430138292799,"ssim":0.9992630497891796},{"page":20,"drift":2.6390081068192655,"ssim":0.99911179753195},{"page":29,"drift":1.7256080114449217,"ssim":0.9993242631796416},{"page":38,"drift":1.06552217453505,"ssim":0.9995554274380076},{"page":39,"drift":1.11311397234144,"ssim":0.999407415874558},{"page":42,"drift":3.2930853600381496,"ssim":0.9958244393832788},{"page":48,"drift":0.5399141630901287,"ssim":0.9997596606013732}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","configuration":"the aggressive setting, for a like-for-like row against /screen","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":37576,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1787209,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":2.5776061039580354,"driftWorst":7.970815450643777,"ssimMean":0.997441601324525,"ssimWorst":0.9837867369872674,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":1.9846447305674773,"ssim":0.9992400945244068},{"page":2,"drift":4.002002861230329,"ssim":0.995725328831957},{"page":10,"drift":2.091368621840725,"ssim":0.9992420034994908},{"page":15,"drift":2.644062947067239,"ssim":0.9992632847765978},{"page":20,"drift":2.6390081068192655,"ssim":0.99911179753195},{"page":29,"drift":1.7256080114449217,"ssim":0.9993242631796416},{"page":38,"drift":1.06552217453505,"ssim":0.9995554274380076},{"page":39,"drift":1.11311397234144,"ssim":0.999407415874558},{"page":42,"drift":7.970815450643777,"ssim":0.9837867369872674},{"page":48,"drift":0.5399141630901287,"ssim":0.9997596606013732}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","configuration":"the command most answers recommend","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":1160,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":983351,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9583919970359392,"drift":1.900410109680496,"driftWorst":7.728659990462565,"ssimMean":0.9702763836571155,"ssimWorst":0.8321094426152317,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.02212684787792084,"ssim":0.9999869980959614},{"page":2,"drift":0.24167858845970436,"ssim":0.9999596376288368},{"page":10,"drift":3.2029566046733433,"ssim":0.8716254206189645},{"page":15,"drift":7.485073915116834,"ssim":0.8321094426152317},{"page":20,"drift":0.02508345255126371,"ssim":0.9999889763691115},{"page":29,"drift":0.013257033857892226,"ssim":0.9999889730550076},{"page":38,"drift":0.2852646638054363,"ssim":0.999959454098988},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999193998532},{"page":42,"drift":7.728659990462565,"ssim":0.9991451629490362},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999998517401648}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":1,"emptied":[{"page":41,"before":35.43,"after":1.37}]},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","configuration":"the aggressive preset","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":887,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":884936,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9583919970359392,"drift":2.5744396757272296,"driftWorst":13.432522651406773,"ssimMean":0.9688811549710602,"ssimWorst":0.8321094426152317,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.02212684787792084,"ssim":0.9999869980959614},{"page":2,"drift":0.3323795898903195,"ssim":0.999855396729002},{"page":10,"drift":3.2029566046733433,"ssim":0.8716254206189645},{"page":15,"drift":7.485073915116834,"ssim":0.8321094426152317},{"page":20,"drift":0.02508345255126371,"ssim":0.9999889763691115},{"page":29,"drift":0.013257033857892226,"ssim":0.9999889730550076},{"page":38,"drift":1.2309966618979495,"ssim":0.9951955152194054},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999193998532},{"page":42,"drift":13.432522651406773,"ssim":0.990061055867899},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999998517401648}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":1,"emptied":[{"page":41,"before":35.43,"after":1.37}]},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","configuration":"the preset that sounds safest","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":1008,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1395510,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9583919970359392,"drift":1.570214592274678,"driftWorst":7.485073915116834,"ssimMean":0.9702591879040312,"ssimWorst":0.8321094426152317,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.20848831664282305,"ssim":0.9996785042415828},{"page":2,"drift":0.033285646161182646,"ssim":0.9999636351528202},{"page":10,"drift":3.2029566046733433,"ssim":0.8716254206189645},{"page":15,"drift":7.485073915116834,"ssim":0.8321094426152317},{"page":20,"drift":0.02508345255126371,"ssim":0.9999889763691115},{"page":29,"drift":0.013257033857892226,"ssim":0.9999889730550076},{"page":38,"drift":0.06914639961850262,"ssim":0.9999815289172458},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999193998532},{"page":42,"drift":4.664854554124941,"ssim":0.9992556269303282},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999998517401648}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":1,"emptied":[{"page":41,"before":35.43,"after":1.37}]},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf — lossless structural optimisation","configuration":"technical reference; no image transcoding","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":675,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":6385802,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":false,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":10,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":15,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":20,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":42,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"qpdf-aggressive","label":"qpdf — --optimize-images","configuration":"technical reference; permits image optimisation","inputBytes":6813639,"runtimeMs":794,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":6165010,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":false,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.01174058178350024,"driftWorst":0.1174058178350024,"ssimMean":0.9999978668797178,"ssimWorst":0.9999788078870302,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":10,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":15,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":20,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":0.1174058178350024,"ssim":0.9999788078870302},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":42,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999998609101473},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com","inputBytes":6813639,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1994302,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.1206771578445398,"driftWorst":7.081640438721984,"ssimMean":0.9998097496142562,"ssimWorst":0.998476620939311,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0.18674296614210775,"ssim":0.9999945256130656},{"page":10,"drift":0.016022889842632334,"ssim":0.9999859303635826},{"page":15,"drift":2.9241773962804007,"ssim":0.9999693797580744},{"page":20,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":0.9981878874582736,"ssim":0.998476620939311},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":42,"drift":7.081640438721984,"ssim":0.9996710446480792},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999948204464}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com; the setting our aggressive one is measured against","inputBytes":6813639,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1914874,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.725302813543157,"driftWorst":11.688412017167382,"ssimMean":0.9996683682036146,"ssimWorst":0.997693546034932,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0.2653314258464473,"ssim":0.9999909411193664},{"page":10,"drift":0.016022889842632334,"ssim":0.9999859303635826},{"page":15,"drift":4.081449690033382,"ssim":0.9998885929387528},{"page":20,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":1.2018121125417265,"ssim":0.997693546034932},{"page":39,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":42,"drift":11.688412017167382,"ssim":0.9991246767590648},{"page":48,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999948204464}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","configuration":"uploaded to tools.pdf24.org","inputBytes":6813639,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":3086463,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":0,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":795,"linksAfter":795,"annotationsBefore":795,"annotationsAfter":795,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.0187887458273726,"driftWorst":6.337339055793992,"ssimMean":0.999760373050272,"ssimWorst":0.9992135231280836,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0.19742489270386265,"ssim":0.9998671258323896},{"page":10,"drift":0.06227944682880305,"ssim":0.999819340837176},{"page":15,"drift":2.723795898903195,"ssim":0.999806384008042},{"page":20,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":0.7274201239866476,"ssim":0.9993824252157852},{"page":39,"drift":0.021268478779208393,"ssim":0.9998835897124644},{"page":42,"drift":6.337339055793992,"ssim":0.9996313417687784},{"page":48,"drift":0.1183595612780162,"ssim":0.9992135231280836}],"pagesMeasured":10,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","configuration":"uploaded to smallpdf.com; free tier allows two downloads per 12 hours","inputBytes":6813639,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"adobe-default","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — default/preselected","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; exact live setting is recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":6813639,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"adobe-smallest","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — strongest free setting","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; paid-only modes are not substituted or inferred","inputBytes":6813639,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"sejda-default","label":"Sejda — current defaults","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":6813639,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"arxiv-clip.pdf","tool":"sejda-smallest","label":"Sejda — strongest reasonable free settings","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":6813639,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","configuration":"in the browser, nothing uploaded","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":7291,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1946567,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":35,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.29178691105252863,"driftWorst":2.1331409331409334,"ssimMean":0.9998136536663712,"ssimWorst":0.9985665356142036,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.03876863876863877,"ssim":0.9998078721375482},{"page":38,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":74,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":96,"drift":0.1871244635193133,"ssim":0.9999847255935445},{"page":111,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":124,"drift":0,"ssim":0.999999851926636},{"page":136,"drift":0.2670481640438722,"ssim":0.9999639195456754},{"page":147,"drift":0,"ssim":0.999999978179734},{"page":184,"drift":2.1331409331409334,"ssim":0.9985665356142036}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","configuration":"the aggressive setting, for a like-for-like row against /screen","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":31618,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1237244,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":35,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.3815662816139688,"driftWorst":2.1545935545935544,"ssimMean":0.999336147834828,"ssimWorst":0.9943450335206488,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.11765271765271763,"ssim":0.9998033064859062},{"page":38,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":74,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":96,"drift":0.19656652360515023,"ssim":0.9999783565074438},{"page":111,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":124,"drift":0.5958035288507391,"ssim":0.9999544966730382},{"page":136,"drift":0.36948020982355745,"ssim":0.9999441591466808},{"page":147,"drift":0,"ssim":0.999999978179734},{"page":184,"drift":2.1545935545935544,"ssim":0.9943450335206488}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","configuration":"the command most answers recommend","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":3566,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":4067245,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":false,"textKept":0.9998895472870564,"drift":8.112972878338955,"driftWorst":12.594754411063423,"ssimMean":0.998542601575717,"ssimWorst":0.9973977058881436,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.3346801346801347,"ssim":0.9973977058881436},{"page":38,"drift":12.594754411063423,"ssim":0.99845205999973},{"page":74,"drift":11.402670481640438,"ssim":0.998539725132998},{"page":96,"drift":10.307868383404864,"ssim":0.998530401794329},{"page":111,"drift":11.717024320457798,"ssim":0.99862125423409},{"page":124,"drift":10.183118741058657,"ssim":0.9986319982171592},{"page":136,"drift":9.879160705770149,"ssim":0.9982921053600666},{"page":147,"drift":5.284732214228617,"ssim":0.9987633481574127},{"page":184,"drift":1.3127465127465126,"ssim":0.999654815397524}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","configuration":"the aggressive preset","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":3410,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":4029887,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":false,"textKept":0.9998895472870564,"drift":8.28651569575397,"driftWorst":12.594754411063423,"ssimMean":0.9969970448442252,"ssimWorst":0.9933007616523336,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.5756613756613757,"ssim":0.9957115327407936},{"page":38,"drift":12.594754411063423,"ssim":0.99845205999973},{"page":74,"drift":11.402670481640438,"ssim":0.998539725132998},{"page":96,"drift":10.839389604196471,"ssim":0.9972047007103608},{"page":111,"drift":11.717024320457798,"ssim":0.99862125423409},{"page":124,"drift":10.414687649022412,"ssim":0.994180067435848},{"page":136,"drift":10.196089651883645,"ssim":0.9933007616523336},{"page":147,"drift":5.284732214228617,"ssim":0.9987633481574127},{"page":184,"drift":1.5536315536315537,"ssim":0.99819995353446}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","configuration":"the preset that sounds safest","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":3339,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":4475580,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":false,"textKept":0.9998895472870564,"drift":0.0392194134957864,"driftWorst":0.1445887445887446,"ssimMean":0.9997027660558548,"ssimWorst":0.9973997644850788,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.1445887445887446,"ssim":0.9973997644850788},{"page":38,"drift":0.04139246542680019,"ssim":0.9999809552657228},{"page":74,"drift":0.02536957558416786,"ssim":0.9999917305445578},{"page":96,"drift":0.03509775870290892,"ssim":0.9999910934987264},{"page":111,"drift":0.03843586075345732,"ssim":0.9999874397195684},{"page":124,"drift":0.030138292799237007,"ssim":0.9999893806919284},{"page":136,"drift":0.023175965665236057,"ssim":0.999995478165655},{"page":147,"drift":0.013429256594724222,"ssim":0.9999893676098858},{"page":184,"drift":0.0013468013468013469,"ssim":0.9999996845215696}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf — lossless structural optimisation","configuration":"technical reference; no image transcoding","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":690,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2272979,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":35,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":74,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":96,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":111,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":124,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":136,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":147,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":184,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"qpdf-aggressive","label":"qpdf — --optimize-images","configuration":"technical reference; permits image optimisation","inputBytes":2417116,"runtimeMs":809,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2273107,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":35,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":38,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":74,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":96,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":111,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":124,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":136,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":147,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":184,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com","inputBytes":2417116,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1371030,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.4553388404021202,"driftWorst":2.0289562289562286,"ssimMean":0.9990785499803254,"ssimWorst":0.994662176260218,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.2683982683982684,"ssim":0.994662176260218},{"page":38,"drift":0.002575107296137339,"ssim":0.999996381895848},{"page":74,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":96,"drift":0.43328564616118265,"ssim":0.9998992501430188},{"page":111,"drift":0.013829279923700526,"ssim":0.999996264582995},{"page":124,"drift":0.762613257033858,"ssim":0.9998832874650492},{"page":136,"drift":0.5391511683357177,"ssim":0.9991781433072028},{"page":147,"drift":0.0492406075139888,"ssim":0.9999512707840038},{"page":184,"drift":2.0289562289562286,"ssim":0.998140175384592}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com; the setting our aggressive one is measured against","inputBytes":2417116,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1300448,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":8.333994992289988,"driftWorst":12.580352885073914,"ssimMean":0.996372677084961,"ssimWorst":0.9834732953489808,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.5359307359307359,"ssim":0.9943844170857002},{"page":38,"drift":12.580352885073914,"ssim":0.998635792654482},{"page":74,"drift":11.392656175488794,"ssim":0.998704438268844},{"page":96,"drift":10.51444921316166,"ssim":0.9986257786591854},{"page":111,"drift":11.705865522174536,"ssim":0.9987780815907668},{"page":124,"drift":10.409060562708632,"ssim":0.9980585757882928},{"page":136,"drift":10.02412970910825,"ssim":0.9978724165352189},{"page":147,"drift":5.301518784972022,"ssim":0.998821297833178},{"page":184,"drift":2.541991341991342,"ssim":0.9834732953489808}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","configuration":"uploaded to tools.pdf24.org","inputBytes":2417116,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2050306,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":25477,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":1,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":35,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.24173854722257204,"driftWorst":0.9419170243204578,"ssimMean":0.9999566715966804,"ssimWorst":0.9998259692886134,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.2813852813852814,"ssim":0.9999606215390368},{"page":38,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":74,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":96,"drift":0.2353838817358131,"ssim":0.999973518669689},{"page":111,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":124,"drift":0.9419170243204578,"ssim":0.9998259692886134},{"page":136,"drift":0.4354792560801145,"ssim":0.9998891534657796},{"page":147,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":184,"drift":0.28148148148148144,"ssim":0.9999607814070058}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","configuration":"uploaded to smallpdf.com; free tier allows two downloads per 12 hours","inputBytes":2417116,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1356409,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":25477,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":1,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":34,"linksAfter":34,"annotationsBefore":35,"annotationsAfter":34,"outlinesBefore":27,"outlinesAfter":27,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":7.991637227349088,"driftWorst":12.580352885073914,"ssimMean":0.9983409920015464,"ssimWorst":0.9945541365446712,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.44675324675324674,"ssim":0.9945541365446712},{"page":38,"drift":12.580352885073914,"ssim":0.998635792654482},{"page":74,"drift":11.392656175488794,"ssim":0.998704438268844},{"page":96,"drift":10.043681449690034,"ssim":0.9988365968769864},{"page":111,"drift":11.705865522174536,"ssim":0.9987780815907668},{"page":124,"drift":10.15021459227468,"ssim":0.9987225531001956},{"page":136,"drift":9.89794945159752,"ssim":0.998177384218504},{"page":147,"drift":5.333812949640287,"ssim":0.9987472626526066},{"page":184,"drift":0.3734487734487734,"ssim":0.9999126821068616}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"adobe-default","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — default/preselected","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; exact live setting is recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":2417116,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"adobe-smallest","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — strongest free setting","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; paid-only modes are not substituted or inferred","inputBytes":2417116,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"sejda-default","label":"Sejda — current defaults","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":2417116,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"budget.pdf","tool":"sejda-smallest","label":"Sejda — strongest reasonable free settings","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":2417116,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","configuration":"in the browser, nothing uploaded","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":10568,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1331508,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.0073862131086735,"driftWorst":6.3785407725321885,"ssimMean":0.9996628374717282,"ssimWorst":0.998187671812693,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":6.3785407725321885,"ssim":0.998187671812693},{"page":3,"drift":0.31025274201239866,"ssim":0.9999478576454964},{"page":4,"drift":0.3251311397234144,"ssim":0.9999364245371426},{"page":14,"drift":0.016404387219837863,"ssim":0.9999969527152672},{"page":19,"drift":2.0361468764902244,"ssim":0.998907532323182},{"page":27,"drift":0,"ssim":0.999995031806166},{"page":41,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999998267284},{"page":54,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999940743017374},{"page":67,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999922771422}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","configuration":"the aggressive setting, for a like-for-like row against /screen","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":39079,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":538743,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.6390610925660996,"driftWorst":10.96061039580353,"ssimMean":0.9994881744211284,"ssimWorst":0.9965993505105102,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":10.96061039580353,"ssim":0.9965993505105102},{"page":3,"drift":0.299380066762041,"ssim":0.999937546833468},{"page":4,"drift":0.3529804482594182,"ssim":0.9999459450563948},{"page":14,"drift":0.016404387219837863,"ssim":0.9999969527152672},{"page":19,"drift":3.1221745350500716,"ssim":0.9989246764627432},{"page":27,"drift":0,"ssim":0.999995031806166},{"page":41,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999998267284},{"page":54,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999940743017374},{"page":67,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999922771422}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","configuration":"the command most answers recommend","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":3827,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":3254681,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":false,"textKept":0.9814636349947296,"drift":5.968152059182411,"driftWorst":17.24902241297091,"ssimMean":0.998258678801746,"ssimWorst":0.9936400826726074,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":12.83996185026228,"ssim":0.9936400826726074},{"page":3,"drift":1.136003814973772,"ssim":0.999686327006447},{"page":4,"drift":0.9667143538388174,"ssim":0.999755847848294},{"page":14,"drift":3.376347162613257,"ssim":0.999036434644212},{"page":19,"drift":17.24902241297091,"ssim":0.998304394733069},{"page":27,"drift":5.672262190247801,"ssim":0.9987868241487964},{"page":41,"drift":3.881831187410586,"ssim":0.9992858366552776},{"page":54,"drift":6.254268001907487,"ssim":0.99687438174905},{"page":67,"drift":2.336957558416786,"ssim":0.99895797975796}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","configuration":"the aggressive preset","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":3949,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":3110335,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":false,"textKept":0.9814636349947296,"drift":7.241717470086878,"driftWorst":22.573199809251314,"ssimMean":0.988099180668639,"ssimWorst":0.9263731810520194,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":22.573199809251314,"ssim":0.9263731810520194},{"page":3,"drift":1.2200286123032904,"ssim":0.9978224062443422},{"page":4,"drift":1.4817358130662852,"ssim":0.9974023700172486},{"page":14,"drift":3.376347162613257,"ssim":0.999036434644212},{"page":19,"drift":18.37882689556509,"ssim":0.9783532117488454},{"page":27,"drift":5.672262190247801,"ssim":0.9987868241487964},{"page":41,"drift":3.881831187410586,"ssim":0.9992858366552776},{"page":54,"drift":6.254268001907487,"ssim":0.99687438174905},{"page":67,"drift":2.336957558416786,"ssim":0.99895797975796}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","configuration":"the preset that sounds safest","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":2865,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":4440086,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":false,"textKept":0.9814636349947296,"drift":0.15222118919075514,"driftWorst":0.6133524082021936,"ssimMean":0.9997516279294656,"ssimWorst":0.9980990399981856,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.0035288507391511683,"ssim":0.9999996478318064},{"page":3,"drift":0.28936576061039576,"ssim":0.999926595198966},{"page":4,"drift":0.0005722460658082975,"ssim":0.9999999938510588},{"page":14,"drift":0.29480209823557463,"ssim":0.9999871284583132},{"page":19,"drift":0.10309966618979494,"ssim":0.9997689654417492},{"page":27,"drift":0.00031974420463629094,"ssim":0.9999951330568788},{"page":41,"drift":0.011826418693371483,"ssim":0.9999923465331688},{"page":54,"drift":0.6133524082021936,"ssim":0.9980990399981856},{"page":67,"drift":0.0531235097758703,"ssim":0.999995800995064}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf — lossless structural optimisation","configuration":"technical reference; no image transcoding","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":443,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2356693,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":3,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":4,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":14,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":19,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":27,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":41,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":54,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":67,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"qpdf-aggressive","label":"qpdf — --optimize-images","configuration":"technical reference; permits image optimisation","inputBytes":2724508,"runtimeMs":473,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2351489,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.000010597149366820326,"driftWorst":0.00009537434430138292,"ssimMean":0.9999997773708924,"ssimWorst":0.9999987986250538,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":3,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999991977129784},{"page":4,"drift":0.00009537434430138292,"ssim":0.9999987986250538},{"page":14,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":19,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":27,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":41,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":54,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":67,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com","inputBytes":2724508,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":697005,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.6319011552798772,"driftWorst":12.124368144969004,"ssimMean":0.9989037382474572,"ssimWorst":0.9932165322715087,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":12.124368144969004,"ssim":0.9932165322715087},{"page":3,"drift":0.3138769670958512,"ssim":0.999930196276262},{"page":4,"drift":0.14153552694325225,"ssim":0.9999926934889292},{"page":14,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999923003692},{"page":19,"drift":2.1050071530758228,"ssim":0.9969988131325396},{"page":27,"drift":0.00031974420463629094,"ssim":0.9999977701569978},{"page":41,"drift":0.0020028612303290417,"ssim":0.9999976466005088},{"page":54,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":67,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com; the setting our aggressive one is measured against","inputBytes":2724508,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":569784,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":6.166268129988142,"driftWorst":20.305102527420125,"ssimMean":0.996149701796156,"ssimWorst":0.9780631546963496,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":20.305102527420125,"ssim":0.9780631546963496},{"page":3,"drift":1.3381020505484025,"ssim":0.9994328776326724},{"page":4,"drift":1.5033857892226992,"ssim":0.9994367337741136},{"page":14,"drift":3.630329041487839,"ssim":0.9990587053638302},{"page":19,"drift":12.032618025751072,"ssim":0.99258914571831},{"page":27,"drift":5.925979216626699,"ssim":0.9988359127457118},{"page":41,"drift":3.9464949928469246,"ssim":0.999340485330699},{"page":54,"drift":6.233476394849785,"ssim":0.998711775945936},{"page":67,"drift":0.5809251311397234,"ssim":0.9998785249577816}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","configuration":"uploaded to tools.pdf24.org","inputBytes":2724508,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1632403,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":34802,"tagsAfter":34802,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":348,"linksAfter":348,"annotationsBefore":348,"annotationsAfter":348,"outlinesBefore":2,"outlinesAfter":2,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":2.802840036030308,"driftWorst":13.565283738674298,"ssimMean":0.999546897877738,"ssimWorst":0.997280750539382,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":11.062470195517406,"ssim":0.997280750539382},{"page":3,"drift":0.2940391034811636,"ssim":0.9999323137715},{"page":4,"drift":0.30376728659990465,"ssim":0.99995281751806},{"page":14,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":19,"drift":13.565283738674298,"ssim":0.9987561990706988},{"page":27,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":41,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":54,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":67,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":9,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","configuration":"uploaded to smallpdf.com; free tier allows two downloads per 12 hours","inputBytes":2724508,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"adobe-default","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — default/preselected","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; exact live setting is recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":2724508,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"adobe-smallest","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — strongest free setting","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; paid-only modes are not substituted or inferred","inputBytes":2724508,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"sejda-default","label":"Sejda — current defaults","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":2724508,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"census.pdf","tool":"sejda-smallest","label":"Sejda — strongest reasonable free settings","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":2724508,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","configuration":"in the browser, nothing uploaded","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":2458,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":126805,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":0.999997406843632,"ssimWorst":0.9999949801623846,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999949801623846},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999998335248796}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","configuration":"the aggressive setting, for a like-for-like row against /screen","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":6145,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":89579,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":0.999997406843632,"ssimWorst":0.9999949801623846,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999949801623846},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999998335248796}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","configuration":"the command most answers recommend","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":395,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":132169,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.7504530281354318,"driftWorst":2.463710061993324,"ssimMean":0.9992207319792212,"ssimWorst":0.9990518289760504,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":2.463710061993324,"ssim":0.9990518289760504},{"page":2,"drift":1.0371959942775395,"ssim":0.999389634982392}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","configuration":"the aggressive preset","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":207,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":132179,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.7504530281354318,"driftWorst":2.463710061993324,"ssimMean":0.9992207319792212,"ssimWorst":0.9990518289760504,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":2.463710061993324,"ssim":0.9990518289760504},{"page":2,"drift":1.0371959942775395,"ssim":0.999389634982392}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","configuration":"the preset that sounds safest","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":196,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":137667,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":false,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":0,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":1.7504530281354318,"driftWorst":2.463710061993324,"ssimMean":0.9992207319792212,"ssimWorst":0.9990518289760504,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":2.463710061993324,"ssim":0.9990518289760504},{"page":2,"drift":1.0371959942775395,"ssim":0.999389634982392}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf — lossless structural optimisation","configuration":"technical reference; no image transcoding","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":81,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":199086,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"qpdf-aggressive","label":"qpdf — --optimize-images","configuration":"technical reference; permits image optimisation","inputBytes":220237,"runtimeMs":82,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":199104,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com","inputBytes":220237,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":168057,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com; the setting our aggressive one is measured against","inputBytes":220237,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":168064,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","configuration":"uploaded to tools.pdf24.org","inputBytes":220237,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":213651,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":1236,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","configuration":"uploaded to smallpdf.com; free tier allows two downloads per 12 hours","inputBytes":220237,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":102520,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":1236,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":199,"formFieldsAfter":199,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":0,"linksAfter":0,"annotationsBefore":199,"annotationsAfter":199,"outlinesBefore":0,"outlinesAfter":0,"attachmentsBefore":0,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":2,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":2,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"adobe-default","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — default/preselected","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; exact live setting is recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":220237,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"adobe-smallest","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — strongest free setting","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; paid-only modes are not substituted or inferred","inputBytes":220237,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"sejda-default","label":"Sejda — current defaults","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":220237,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-1040.pdf","tool":"sejda-smallest","label":"Sejda — strongest reasonable free settings","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":220237,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"lyonite","label":"Lyonite — Balanced (default)","configuration":"in the browser, nothing uploaded","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":10892,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":2698013,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.0895837591116561,"driftWorst":0.4715307582260372,"ssimMean":0.999968226532819,"ssimWorst":0.9998351562803576,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.0882212684787792,"ssim":0.999979524347352},{"page":29,"drift":0.02832618025751073,"ssim":0.9999817206431528},{"page":57,"drift":0.004768717215069146,"ssim":0.999998995358092},{"page":86,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999201123368},{"page":114,"drift":0.4715307582260372,"ssim":0.9998351562803576},{"page":131,"drift":0.014401525989508822,"ssim":0.9999929359254712},{"page":142,"drift":0.01983786361468765,"ssim":0.9999893330629716}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"lyonite-smallest","label":"Lyonite — Smallest","configuration":"the aggressive setting, for a like-for-like row against /screen","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":53132,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1444567,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.08955650929899857,"driftWorst":0.4715307582260372,"ssimMean":0.9999680322550218,"ssimWorst":0.9998337043122808,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.0882212684787792,"ssim":0.999979524347352},{"page":29,"drift":0.02832618025751073,"ssim":0.9999817206431528},{"page":57,"drift":0.004768717215069146,"ssim":0.9999989818631722},{"page":86,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999201123368},{"page":114,"drift":0.4715307582260372,"ssim":0.9998337043122808},{"page":131,"drift":0.014210777300906056,"ssim":0.9999930414438872},{"page":142,"drift":0.01983786361468765,"ssim":0.9999893330629716}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"gs-ebook","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/ebook","configuration":"the command most answers recommend","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":17716,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":7056010,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":false,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2955,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2955,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"drift":12.242128210368554,"driftWorst":28.19866475917978,"ssimMean":0.9976108284769027,"ssimWorst":0.9938307878900354,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":28.19866475917978,"ssim":0.9938307878900354},{"page":29,"drift":8.396852646638054,"ssim":0.9983627124296972},{"page":57,"drift":11.042918454935622,"ssim":0.998087048131338},{"page":86,"drift":12.272007629947543,"ssim":0.9983520199720676},{"page":114,"drift":10.296137339055797,"ssim":0.997896777332704},{"page":131,"drift":10.67172150691464,"ssim":0.9977438359898392},{"page":142,"drift":4.8165951359084405,"ssim":0.9990026175926394}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"gs-screen","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/screen","configuration":"the aggressive preset","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":16931,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":7057060,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":false,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2955,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2955,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"drift":12.242141835274882,"driftWorst":28.19866475917978,"ssimMean":0.997561329650014,"ssimWorst":0.9938307878900354,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":28.19866475917978,"ssim":0.9938307878900354},{"page":29,"drift":8.396852646638054,"ssim":0.9983627124296972},{"page":57,"drift":11.042918454935622,"ssim":0.998087048131338},{"page":86,"drift":12.272007629947543,"ssim":0.9983520199720676},{"page":114,"drift":10.296137339055797,"ssim":0.997896777332704},{"page":131,"drift":10.67181688125894,"ssim":0.9973973442016176},{"page":142,"drift":4.8165951359084405,"ssim":0.9990026175926394}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"gs-printer","label":"Ghostscript -dPDFSETTINGS=/printer","configuration":"the preset that sounds safest","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":17113,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":7267608,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":false,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2955,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2955,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":0,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"drift":0.4558621159479528,"driftWorst":1.0189794945159754,"ssimMean":0.999812509455038,"ssimWorst":0.9993926374016848,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.06695278969957082,"ssim":0.9999991507517368},{"page":29,"drift":0.7742489270386266,"ssim":0.999811052628644},{"page":57,"drift":0.2131616595135908,"ssim":0.9997435268480408},{"page":86,"drift":0.04663805436337625,"ssim":0.999982568150987},{"page":114,"drift":1.0189794945159754,"ssim":0.9999961196263834},{"page":131,"drift":0.3163567000476872,"ssim":0.9993926374016848},{"page":142,"drift":0.7546971864568431,"ssim":0.9997625107777895}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"qpdf","label":"qpdf — lossless structural optimisation","configuration":"technical reference; no image transcoding","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":1179,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":3089210,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":57,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":86,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":114,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":131,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":142,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"qpdf-aggressive","label":"qpdf — --optimize-images","configuration":"technical reference; permits image optimisation","inputBytes":3088632,"runtimeMs":1513,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":3089543,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":false,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0,"driftWorst":0,"ssimMean":1,"ssimWorst":1,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":57,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":86,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":114,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":131,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":142,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf","label":"iLovePDF — Recommended (default)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com","inputBytes":3088632,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1709735,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"drift":0.12570338578922272,"driftWorst":0.4546494992846925,"ssimMean":0.9998539821390694,"ssimWorst":0.9994159294948136,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0.001144492131616595,"ssim":0.999999864091048},{"page":29,"drift":0.07401049117787314,"ssim":0.9999250714913502},{"page":57,"drift":0.11597520267048164,"ssim":0.9997650494705512},{"page":86,"drift":0.0078206962327134,"ssim":0.999996413306933},{"page":114,"drift":0.4546494992846925,"ssim":0.9998859819117228},{"page":131,"drift":0.1876013352408202,"ssim":0.9994159294948136},{"page":142,"drift":0.03872198378636147,"ssim":0.9999895652070668}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"ilovepdf-extreme","label":"iLovePDF — Extreme (its most aggressive)","configuration":"uploaded to ilovepdf.com; the setting our aggressive one is measured against","inputBytes":3088632,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":1716593,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":true},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":0,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":0.9999987408618044,"drift":11.550814088153144,"driftWorst":24.308154506437766,"ssimMean":0.9980024456596732,"ssimWorst":0.9947672289130256,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":24.308154506437766,"ssim":0.9947672289130256},{"page":29,"drift":7.973581306628517,"ssim":0.9986507063096158},{"page":57,"drift":10.98817358130663,"ssim":0.998286363078723},{"page":86,"drift":12.250453028135432,"ssim":0.9985236479961256},{"page":114,"drift":10.028040057224606,"ssim":0.9984077589062827},{"page":131,"drift":10.583977110157369,"ssim":0.9980199281842542},{"page":142,"drift":4.723319027181688,"ssim":0.9993614862296842}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"pdf24","label":"PDF24 — 144 dpi, quality 75 (default)","configuration":"uploaded to tools.pdf24.org","inputBytes":3088632,"qpdfValid":true,"outputBytes":3109949,"targetSuccess":{"10MB":true,"5MB":true,"2MB":false},"uploads":true,"pagesOk":true,"tagsBefore":62494,"tagsAfter":62494,"formFieldsBefore":0,"formFieldsAfter":0,"formValuesOk":true,"linksBefore":2958,"linksAfter":2958,"annotationsBefore":2958,"annotationsAfter":2958,"outlinesBefore":12,"outlinesAfter":12,"attachmentsBefore":1,"attachmentsAfter":1,"pageGeometryOk":true,"textKept":1,"drift":0.001253491382246747,"driftWorst":0.00877443967572723,"ssimMean":0.99999882968536,"ssimWorst":0.999991811755804,"visualPages":[{"page":1,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":29,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":57,"drift":0,"ssim":0.9999999960417174},{"page":86,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":114,"drift":0,"ssim":1},{"page":131,"drift":0.00877443967572723,"ssim":0.999991811755804},{"page":142,"drift":0,"ssim":1}],"pagesMeasured":7,"pagesEmptied":0},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"smallpdf","label":"Smallpdf — Basic (the only free level)","configuration":"uploaded to smallpdf.com; free tier allows two downloads per 12 hours","inputBytes":3088632,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"adobe-default","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — default/preselected","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; exact live setting is recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":3088632,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"adobe-smallest","label":"Adobe Acrobat Online — strongest free setting","configuration":"uploaded to Adobe; paid-only modes are not substituted or inferred","inputBytes":3088632,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"sejda-default","label":"Sejda — current defaults","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":3088632,"error":"no saved output for this file"},{"file":"irs-p17.pdf","tool":"sejda-smallest","label":"Sejda — strongest reasonable free settings","configuration":"uploaded to Sejda; exact controls are recorded in results/web/manifest.json","inputBytes":3088632,"error":"no saved output for this file"}]},"webManifest":{"schemaVersion":1,"observedAt":"2026-08-29","accessPolicy":"Free product access only. Paid-only modes are labelled untested and are never replaced with guessed results.","services":[{"id":"adobe-default","product":"Adobe Acrobat Online","category":"consumer-service","uploads":true,"setting":"Medium compression","defaultStatus":"Adobe documents High, Medium and Low but its public pre-upload page does not expose a stable preselected value. Medium is the declared normal-comparison analogue, not claimed as preselected.","freeAccess":"limited use","measured":false,"source":"https://www.adobe.com/acrobat/online/compress-pdf.html"},{"id":"adobe-smallest","product":"Adobe Acrobat Online","category":"consumer-service","uploads":true,"setting":"High compression (smallest size, lower quality)","defaultStatus":"Explicit strongest documented level","freeAccess":"limited use; paid-only capabilities are out of scope","measured":false,"source":"https://helpx.adobe.com/acrobat/mobile/share-files/compress.html"},{"id":"sejda-default","product":"Sejda","category":"consumer-service","uploads":true,"setting":{"imageQuality":"Medium / JPEG 65%","imageResolutionPpi":72,"imageConversion":"None","multimedia":"Unconfirmed until output capture","fonts":"Unconfirmed until output capture"},"defaultStatus":"The live product page states JPEG 65% and 72 PPI as standard settings. Remaining toggle defaults must be captured with the output.","freeAccess":"up to 200 pages or 100 MB, three tasks per hour, one file per task","measured":false,"source":"https://www.sejda.com/compress-pdf"},{"id":"sejda-smallest","product":"Sejda","category":"consumer-service","uploads":true,"setting":{"imageQuality":"Medium / JPEG 65%","imageResolutionPpi":72,"imageConversion":"Grayscale","multimedia":"Discard","fonts":"Optimize (experimental)"},"defaultStatus":"Explicit aggressive configuration for the absolute-smallest leaderboard; grayscale loss is disclosed.","freeAccess":"same free limits as default","measured":false,"source":"https://www.sejda.com/compress-pdf"},{"id":"smallpdf-strongest","product":"Smallpdf","category":"consumer-service","setting":"Strong compression","measured":false,"reason":"Paid-only in the observed product; excluded under the free-access test policy. Basic remains the measured free row."}]}}